Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Regarding the Hadeeth About Losing Your Eyesight if you Look Up During Salah

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Regarding the Hadeeth About Losing Your Eyesight if you Look Up During Salah

    Argument:

    We read in Saheeh Bukhari, Vol. 1, Book 12, Hadith 717:

    Narrated Anas bin Malik:

    The Prophet said, "What is wrong with those people who look towards the sky during the prayer?" His talk grew stern while delivering this speech and he said, "They should stop (looking towards the sky during the prayer); otherwise their eyesight would be taken away."

    Why is looking toward the sky such a great sin worthy of such a punishment? Also, it has not been scientifically proven that people lose their eyesight after doing such a thing.

    Response:

    Looking toward the sky during prayer is sinful because it's displaying bad manners toward Allah, for one should humble himself by tilting his head in a form of submission [1] and it also distorts the reality of ascribing Allah with the lofty position He is worthy of [2]. A few scholars were of the opinion that looking up toward the sky during Salah would nullify the Salah because it would result in diverting away from the Qiblah [3].

    As for this threat of punishment not being "scientifically proven", one should first ask how such a thing could be proven or disproven scientifically anyways. The hadith didn't say that the taking away of the eyesight would necessarily be instant and there is the possibility of someone repenting before Allah decides to inflict that person with this punishment. Someone may possibly lose his eye sight several decades later after doing this act and he might not be aware of the cause of his blindness. One would also need to bear in mind that this punishment wouldn't necessarily be inflicted upon someone who does it out of ignorance, for it was reported that even the Prophet (peace be upon him) used to look toward the sky during prayer before it was revealed to him that he should stop [4]. So the question is... which Muslim nowadays would do this sin knowingly and persistently without the intention of repenting?

    In conclusion, there is nothing unreasonable about the punishment prescribed for this act, nor could this hadith be rejected on the grounds that it has been falsified scientifically.

    Footnotes:

    1) Shaykh al-'Uthaymeen in his abridged commentary on Buloogh al-Maram said: هذه معصية منهي عنها والسبب في هذا انه سوء أدب مع الله تعالى لان المصلي ينبغي له أن يخضع ويطمن رأسه ولا يرفع بصره إلى السماء

    2) Mulla Ali Qari in his commentary on Mishkaat al-Masaabeeh said: لأن ذلك يوهم نسبة العلو المكاني إلى الله تعالى تعالى الله عن ذلك علوا كبيرا

    3) Shaykh al-'Uthaymeen in his commentary on Riyaadh us-Saaliheen said: إن الإنسان مأمور بأن يستقبل القبلة بجميع بدنه فإذا رفع بصره إلى السماء صار وجهه إلى السماء لا إلى القبلة فتبطل صلاته

    4) This was reported by Ibn Sirin in Musannaf ibn Abi Shaybah: حدثنا هشيم عن ابن عون عن ابن سيرين قال : كان رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم مما ينظر إلى الشيء في الصلاة فيرفع بصره حتى نزلت آية إن لم تكن هذه فلا أدري ما هي الذين هم في صلاتهم خاشعون قال : فوضع النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم رأسه .
    www.call-to-monotheism.com

  • #2
    What I thought was that the Muslims back then prayed in a masjid without ceilings and it would not be good for they eyes to look into the sun!
    Beware of writing something that will be against you on the Day of Judgment. Always ask yourself why am I posting to this particular thread and what if I just do not post, what will happen and what change will it brings forth! Try not to socilize alot with people and focus on improving yourself. Set for yourself a daily portion of dhikr or Quran to do. Do a good deed that no one will ever know about but Allah and save this hidden deed, even if it is small, in hope it will save you from the fire.

    Comment


    • #3
      2) Mulla Ali Qari in his commentary on Mishkaat al-Masaabeeh said: لأن ذلك يوهم نسبة العلو المكاني إلى الله تعالى تعالى الله عن ذلك علوا كبيرا
      Anyone else see the above as problematic?

      Also the translation appears to euphemize what the Arabic is actually stating. Seems like the Arabic is saying that the problem with looking up in the prayer is that doing so gives the impression of a 'spatial elevation' to Allah when He is exalted above that by 'a great[er] loftiness'.

      It also seems strange to me that a person would include this sandwiched in between the statements of Ibn al-Uthaymeen...


      Comment


      • #4
        Assalaamu `Alaykum wa Rahmatullaahi wa Barakaatuh.

        Shaykh, I think there is an error here:

        لأن ذلك يوهم نسبة العلو المكاني إلى الله تعالى تعالى الله عن ذلك علوا كبيرا

        You translated this statement as:

        "and it also distorts the reality of ascribing Allah with the lofty position He is worthy of"

        This translation is incorrect.

        Wahhama - Yuwahhimu - Tawheeman (`alaa Baab-it-Taf`eel), means "Awqa`a fil Wahm", and this gives the meaning of "To make someone think or believe (a certain thing); to give the false impression (that a certain thing is a particular way)". That is the meaning of this "Yuwahhimu" used in this sentence. Thus, the correct translation would be:

        "For doing so would give the false impression that Allaah Ta`aalaa is attributed with the direction of being above; Far removed is Allaah Ta`aalaa from such a thing."

        This is the correct translation, and this translation is backed up with the fact that Mullah `Ali Al-Qaari (Rahimahullaah) was an Ash`ari who believed that Allaah Ta`aalaa existed without a place.

        We should strive to translate the statements directly as they are, without changing them to suit our views. It they are in conflict with our views let them be in conflict with our views. It is not correct to translate incorrectly simply to make it seem (Yuwahhimu would be used here, if I was speaking Arabic) that Mullah `Ali Qaari agreed with this view of Ithbaatu Sifatil `Uluwwi Lillaahi Ta`aalaa.

        Baarakallaahu feek, and Jazaakallaah for a beneficial post.

        Was-Salaam.
        ندور مع السنة حيث دارت

        Comment

        Working...
        X